SQL Server Query Processing Puzzle: LIKE vs ?

Adam Machanic — Tue, 22 Apr 2008 14:18:00 GMT

How creative are you with manipulating your queries to produce more efficient plans? Try the following puzzle and e-mail your solution to me at [<do_not_mail> @ do_not_mail.com]. Make sure to include an explanation of why it works, as well as your mailing address. The best two solutions/explanations win a free copy of Expert SQL Server 2005 Development, a wonderful feeling of accomplishment, plus eternal fame and glory when I reveal your solutions here on the blog.

Run the following T-SQL to create two tables in TempDB:

USE TempDB
GO

CREATE TABLE b1 (blat1 CHAR(5) NOT NULL)
CREATE TABLE b2 (blat2 VARCHAR(200) NOT NULL)
GO

INSERT b1
SELECT LEFT(AddressLine1, 5) AS blat1
FROM AdventureWorks.Person.Address

INSERT b2
SELECT AddressLine1 AS blat2
FROM AdventureWorks.Person.Address
GO

Now consider the following query:

SELECT *
FROM b1
JOIN b2 ON
    b2.blat2 LIKE b1.blat1 + '%'

This query takes around three minutes to run on my notebook, and does over 1.8 million logical reads. Can you figure out a way to re-write it so that it performs better? No modification of the base tables or addition of any other objects is allowed (sorry, no indexed views!) -- the challenge is to tune this by doing nothing more than re-writing the query.

Good luck! I'll leave the contest open for submissions until May 1.

Adam Machanic : puzzle, Performance

SQL Server Query Processing Puzzle: LIKE vs ?